Gourmet Marshmallows Made with Real Marshmallow Root & Beef Gelatin, No Corn Syrup

Watermelon marshmallows with pink sugar‑dusted tops and tiny black seed‑style details piled together, highlighting extra‑large, clean‑label marshmallows made with Halal beef gelatin and organic marshmallow root for a corn‑syrup‑free, gluten‑free treat. Watermelon marshmallows with pink sugar‑dusted tops and tiny black seed‑style details piled together, highlighting extra‑large, clean‑label marshmallows made with Halal beef gelatin and organic marshmallow root for a corn‑syrup‑free, gluten‑free treat.
Spring's Here!

The Warm-Up Starts Here

Watermelon Marshmallows
Grab It Now
Two gourmet Orange Dreamsicle marshmallows sit slightly behind one in the foreground on a white plate, emphasizing their fluffy texture, vibrant orange swirls, and creamy vanilla hues. Two gourmet Orange Dreamsicle marshmallows sit slightly behind one in the foreground on a white plate, emphasizing their fluffy texture, vibrant orange swirls, and creamy vanilla hues.
Remember Me?

Orange Dreamsicle

Your Creamsicle Fix
grab it now
three huckleberry pie marshmallows three huckleberry pie marshmallows
I'll be your

Huckleberry

I AM one you're looking for
Seasonal Flavors Shop All

Gourmet Marshmallows Made with Real Marshmallow Root & Beef Gelatin, No Corn Syrup

Discover handcrafted marshmallows made with organic marshmallow root, real beef gelatin, natural colors, and no corn syrup. Each small-batch drop is clean-label, craveable, and only available for a limited time. Shop now before they melt away.

Three pieces of Banana Cream Pie gourmet marshmallows made with organic marshmallow root and premium beef gelatin, topped with a crumbly topping, on a white plate.
I'm baaaaack

Banana Cream Pie!

Grab it!
Any Flavor....Customized

Signature Slab- Marshmallow Sheet

Custom, Clean-label, Craveable
Grab It! Shop All

Forbidden Fruit! Bubble Gum!

Marshmallow of the Month Club!

Grab It! Shop All
New Release!

Root Beer FLOAT

Nostalgic soda‑shop flavor
Shop This Shop All

Discover Gourmet Marshmallows Made with real ingredients – Shop by Category

A clean-label assortment of handcrafted gourmet marshmallows made with organic marshmallow root and beef gelatin, arranged on a white background. The marshmallows feature vibrant colors and seasonal flavors, all corn-syrup free and mostly gluten-free
All Gourmet Marshmallows
Seasonal Flavors
Seasonal Flavors
fresh new release!

Horchata!

Warm Cinnamon Cream
grab it
New
Three creamy horchata marshmallows dusted with cinnamon on top and bottom, naturally color‑free and made with beef gelatin and organic marshmallow root.
A trio of handmade horchata marshmallows showing natural creamy color and cinnamon dusting, crafted with beef gelatin and organic marshmallow root.
Flavor Release!

Mint Chocolate Chip

Minty and Chocolatey
Grab This Shop Marshmallows

Best Sellers

View all
Three s’mores marshmallows stacked on a white plate with chocolate and graham pieces visible against a yellow striped background.
S’mores Marshmallows with Organic Marshmallow Root
$7.81
Three toasted coconut marshmallows stacked on a white plate with a yellow striped background and a Toasty S’more label at the bottom.
Toasted Coconut Marshmallows with Organic Marshmallow Root
$7.64
Creme Brulee dessert with a striped yellow and white background, featuring The Toasty Smore brand.
Creme Brulee Gourmet Marshmallows (3-pack) GF
$7.64
Sold Out
Three cookies & cream marshmallows made with beef gelatin, organic marshmallow root, and no corn syrup, arranged on a white plate against a yellow and white striped background. Each handcrafted marshmallow measures approximately 2" x 2" x 2" and features The Toasty S’more logo alongside a “Made in USA” badge, highlighting artisanal quality and ingredient transparency.
Cookies & Cream Gourmet Marshmallows (3-pack) GF
$7.75
View all
35 products

Join Our

Marshmallow of the Month Club!

Get 6 featured plus 6 curated rotating flavors, and a surprise gift every month! February is Red Velvet Cake Marshmallows!

Sign Up Now!