Can't Decide?

Easy Decisions!

with curated bundle packs!
Shop Bundles Shop all
Want to Pick Exact Flavors?

Custom Gourmet Marshmallow Variety Pack!

You're In Charge!
Custom Variety Packs Shop All

Limited Time Gourmet Marshmallows

Exclusive Seasonal Flavors – Grab Your Gourmet Marshmallows Before They’re Gone!

Perfect Gift!

Chocolate Lover's Bundle!

Grab It! Shop All Bundles
An exquisite two-tiered display elegantly arranged with our best-selling gourmet marshmallows. The tiers are filled with an array of fluffy, colorful marshmallows in a variety of mouth-watering flavors. The beautiful presentation on the fancy plate adds a touch of elegance, making the marshmallows look as irresistible as they taste.
Effortless Choice

Best Sellers Bundle

Discover our top favorites in one irresistible package!
Shop This Shop All

Discover Your Favorite Gourmet Marshmallows – Shop by Category

A colorful display of handcrafted gourmet marshmallows arranged on a white background. The marshmallows come in various flavors, showcasing vibrant colors and appealing presentation.
All Gourmet Marshmallows
gourmet marshmallows all in a bundle pack
Bundle Marshmallow Packs
The Holiday Shop
The Holiday Shop
Customized Variety Packs
Custom Variety Packs
A gloved hand gently lifts one extra-large Butterbeer marshmallow from a clean, white plate, showcasing its pillowy texture. Two more marshmallows rest behind it, emphasizing their handcrafted, USA-made quality. Made with premium gelatin and no corn syrup, these gourmet treats are perfect for s’mores, desserts, or gifting.
New Release!

Butter Beer

Where Magic Meets Marshmallow!
Shop This Shop All

Best Sellers

View all
A plate of delicious s'mores stacked in a tempting display. Each s'more consists of a perfectly toasted marshmallow, slightly melted between layers of gooey chocolate and crisp graham crackers. The marshmallows are golden brown, and the chocolate is beginning to melt, creating a mouthwatering combination. The plate is set against a yellow and white striped background, evoking a cozy candy store atmosphere.
S'mores Gourmet Marshmallows
from $4.53
Best Seller Gourmet Marshmallow Bundle
$9.64
Three cookie dough marshmallows on a white plate, displayed on a yellow and white striped background. The image features The Toasty Smore logo and a "Made in USA" flag.
Cookie Dough Gourmet Marshmallows
from $4.53
A white plate featuring a vibrant assortment of birthday-themed marshmallows in flavors: birthday cake, cotton candy, blue raspberry, cookie dough, cookies & cream, and mint oreo.
Birthday Wish Gourmet Marshmallow Bundle
$9.64
View all
48 products
Three vibrant cherry limeade gourmet marshmallows, swirled in red and green, rest on a minimalist white plate—each cube a fluffy 2" handcrafted delight

Join Our

Marshmallow of the Month Club!

Get 6 featured, 6 curated rotating flavors, and a surprise gift every month! This month is Cherry Limeade Marshmallows!

Sign Up Now!