Handcrafted marshmallows with organic marshmallow root and beef gelatin
Pumpkin Spice and Everything Nice!

It's Fall Y'all!

“Get toasted—Autumn style.”
12 Fall Flavors Pack Shop All
Exciting Release!

Made with organic marshmallow root

Soothe Your Cravings Now!
Shop Bundles Shop all

Limited-Time Marshmallow Bundles Made with Organic Marshmallow Root & Beef Gelatin

Discover handcrafted marshmallow bundles made with organic marshmallow root, real beef gelatin, and no corn syrup. Each small-batch drop is clean-label, craveable, and only available for a limited time. Shop now before they melt away.

Assorted pieces of gourmet marshmallows on a plate with 'The Toasty S’more' logo and 'Baker’s Dream' text. Includes Banana Cream Pie, Lemon Pound Cake, and Strawberry Cheesecake. Made with beef gelatin, organic marshmallow root, no corn syrup, and soy-free base.
Your Irresistible Bundle

Baker's Dream

Grab It! Shop All Bundles
Effortless Choice

Party Favorites Bundle

Be the life of the party!
Shop This Shop All

Discover Gourmet Marshmallows Made with real ingredients – Shop by Category

A colorful display of handcrafted gourmet marshmallows arranged on a white background. The marshmallows come in various flavors, showcasing vibrant colors and appealing presentation.
All Gourmet Marshmallows
best made in usa gourmet marshmallow bundles by the toasty smore
Bundle Marshmallow Packs
The Holiday Shop
The Holiday Shop
New Release!

Cinnamon Roll!

Warm Bliss in Every Bite
Shop This Shop All

Best Sellers

View all
Sold Out
A plate of delicious s’mores stacked enticingly, featuring perfectly toasted golden-brown marshmallows made with premium beef gelatin and soothing organic marshmallow root. These clean-label marshmallows are melted slightly between layers of gooey chocolate and crisp graham crackers, creating a mouthwatering treat. The plate sits on a yellow and white striped background, evoking the warmth and charm of a cozy candy store.
S’mores Gourmet Marshmallows – Organic Root & Beef Gelatin (3-Pack)
$7.44
Three pieces of Banana Cream Pie gourmet marshmallows made with organic marshmallow root and premium beef gelatin, displayed on a plate with a colorful striped background and The Toasty S’more logo.
Banana Cream Pie Gourmet Marshmallows (3-Pack) Beef Gelatin GF
$7.14
Sold Out
Three handcrafted Cotton Candy marshmallows displayed on a yellow and white striped background. The Toasty S’more logo and a “Made in USA” flag are visible, reinforcing artisanal quality and American-made pride. Made with organic marshmallow root and beef gelatin—no corn syrup, gluten, or dairy.
Cotton Candy Gourmet Marshmallows (3-pack) GF
$7.14
Handcrafted toasted coconut marshmallows made with beef gelatin, organic marshmallow root, and no corn syrup, displayed against a vibrant yellow and white striped background. Each marshmallow measures approximately 2" x 2" x 1.5", showcasing a soft, fluffy texture with golden coconut flakes. The Toasty S’more logo and a “Made in USA” flag highlight artisanal quality and American craftsmanship.
Toasted Coconut Gourmet Marshmallows (3-pack) GF
$7.28
View all
33 products

Join Our

Marshmallow of the Month Club!

Get 6 featured plus 6 curated rotating flavors, and a surprise gift every month! November is Sweet Potato Casserole with maple-glazed pecans!

Sign Up Now!