A plate featuring various flavors and colors of gourmet marshmallows by The Toasty Smore. The vibrant marshmallows are displayed on a yellow and white striped background, with a "Made in USA" flag prominently visible. The assortment showcases a delightful range of textures and hues, emphasizing the artisanal craftsmanship of the marshmallows.
Variety Pack of Gourmet Marshmallows – You Choose The Flavors
Various flavors and colors of gourmet marshmallows by The Toasty Smore, spaced out on a clean, white background. The vibrant marshmallows showcase a delightful range of textures and hues, emphasizing the artisanal craftsmanship
A plate featuring various flavors and colors of gourmet marshmallows by The Toasty Smore. The vibrant marshmallows are displayed on a clean, white background. The assortment showcases a delightful range of textures and hues, emphasizing the artisanal craftsmanship of the marshmallows.
Three cotton candy flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a pastel pink hue, embodying the classic colors associated with cotton candy. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three butter vanilla flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a light yellow hue, embodying the classic colors associated with butter vanilla. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three Double Dutch Chocolate flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a rich, dark brown hue, embodying the decadent and indulgent nature of chocolate. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three toasted coconut flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a light beige hue, topped with golden brown toasted coconut flakes. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three strawberry cheesecake flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a soft pink hue, topped with bits of graham crackers. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
video showing a plate of a Variety of Gourmet Marshmallows in Assorted Colors and Flavors Spread Out on a White Plate with a White Background
A close-up view of three pineapple-inspired gourmet marshmallows, handcrafted and made in the USA by The Toasty Smore, arranged on a white plate with one marshmallow in front and two in the back. Each marshmallow is yellow with a green sugar topping, resembling a pineapple. Their soft, fluffy texture contrasts with the sparkling sugar, highlighting their artisanal quality. The arrangement adds depth to the image, showcasing the marshmallows as a vibrant tropical treat.
A close-up view of three watermelon-inspired gourmet marshmallows, handcrafted and
Variety Pack of Gourmet Marshmallows – You Choose The Flavors
Three handcrafted salted caramel gourmet marshmallows aligned in a perfect row on a crisp white background, showcasing their delicate golden caramel swirls and pillowy texture. These artisan confections offer a rich, sweet-and-salty indulgence, ideal for luxury dessert lovers seeking premium treats.
A plate featuring various flavors and colors of gourmet marshmallows by The Toasty Smore. The vibrant marshmallows are displayed on a yellow and white striped background, with a "Made in USA" flag prominently visible. The assortment showcases a delightful range of textures and hues, emphasizing the artisanal craftsmanship of the marshmallows.
Variety Pack of Gourmet Marshmallows – You Choose The Flavors
Various flavors and colors of gourmet marshmallows by The Toasty Smore, spaced out on a clean, white background. The vibrant marshmallows showcase a delightful range of textures and hues, emphasizing the artisanal craftsmanship
A plate featuring various flavors and colors of gourmet marshmallows by The Toasty Smore. The vibrant marshmallows are displayed on a clean, white background. The assortment showcases a delightful range of textures and hues, emphasizing the artisanal craftsmanship of the marshmallows.
Three cotton candy flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a pastel pink hue, embodying the classic colors associated with cotton candy. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three butter vanilla flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a light yellow hue, embodying the classic colors associated with butter vanilla. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three Double Dutch Chocolate flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a rich, dark brown hue, embodying the decadent and indulgent nature of chocolate. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three toasted coconut flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a light beige hue, topped with golden brown toasted coconut flakes. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
Three strawberry cheesecake flavored marshmallows, displayed on a clean, white background. Each marshmallow has a soft pink hue, topped with bits of graham crackers. The soft, fluffy texture and uniform shape of the marshmallows emphasize the artisanal quality and delightful appearance of these gourmet treats.
video showing a plate of a Variety of Gourmet Marshmallows in Assorted Colors and Flavors Spread Out on a White Plate with a White Background
A close-up view of three pineapple-inspired gourmet marshmallows, handcrafted and made in the USA by The Toasty Smore, arranged on a white plate with one marshmallow in front and two in the back. Each marshmallow is yellow with a green sugar topping, resembling a pineapple. Their soft, fluffy texture contrasts with the sparkling sugar, highlighting their artisanal quality. The arrangement adds depth to the image, showcasing the marshmallows as a vibrant tropical treat.
A close-up view of three watermelon-inspired gourmet marshmallows, handcrafted and
Variety Pack of Gourmet Marshmallows – You Choose The Flavors
Three handcrafted salted caramel gourmet marshmallows aligned in a perfect row on a crisp white background, showcasing their delicate golden caramel swirls and pillowy texture. These artisan confections offer a rich, sweet-and-salty indulgence, ideal for luxury dessert lovers seeking premium treats.

Variety Pack of Gourmet Marshmallows – You Choose The Flavors

$4.53
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Choose Quantity
  • In stock, ready to ship
  • Backordered, shipping soon

Handcrafted Gourmet Marshmallows – Variety Pack in ANY Flavor

Description: Indulge in our Handcrafted Gourmet Marshmallows, meticulously cut to approximately 2" x 2" x 2". Choose any flavors from our extensive list below and total the number of marshmallows you want- just write in the "ask a question" drop-down menu. If you have a specific flavor request, just let us know! Each marshmallow is crafted with love using sugar, invert sugar, flavorings, potato starch, and premium beef gelatin.  This does NOT include the chocolate lovers bundle.

To pick your flavors, simply click the "ask a question" drop-down menu, type in the flavors you would like, including your contact information, and that's that! This does NOT include the chocolate lovers bundle items.

Included Flavors:

  • Double Dutch Chocolate 🍫 (contains cocoa powder)

  • Butter Vanilla 🍦

  • Toasted Coconut 🥥 (contains coconut)

  • Birthday Cake 🎂 (contains sprinkles)

  • Cotton Candy 🍧

  • Lemon Pound Cake 🍋

  • Strawberry Cheesecake 🍰 (contains graham crackers with soy and wheat)

  • Dulce De Leche 🍮

  • Caramel Churro 🍟

  • Mint Cookie🍪 (contains gluten-free cookies that start with O – allergen: soy)

  • Lavender and Honey 🍯

  • Creamy Taro 🌸

  • Rose and Pistachio 🧁 (contains pistachios)

  • Champagne and Sugar 🥂

  • S’mores 🥮 (contains semi-sweet chocolate chips and graham crackers with soy/wheat)

  • Junket with Blueberries 💙

  • Almond Cake 🌰 (contains almonds)

  • Rose Pudding 🌹

  • Strawberries in White Custard Sauce 🍓

  • Pears in Wine Syrup 🍐

  • Gingerbread 🥮

  • Mango Chamoy 🥭

  • Wild Cherry Chip 🍒🍫

  • Blue Raspberry 🔵

  • Key Lime Pie 🥧 (contains wheat & soy)

  • Mint 🍃

  • Black Licorice 🖤

  • Cookies & Cream 🍦(contains gluten-free cookies that start with O – allergen: soy)

  • Cookie Dough 🍪

  • Cherry Limeade 🍒
  • Tiramisu 🥮 (with real Italian ladyfinger cookies)

  • Orange Dreamsicle 📙

  • Banana Split 🍨

  • Pineapple 🍍

  • Coffee ☕

  • Watermelon 🍉

  • Tutti Frutti 🌈

  • Salted Caramel 🍮

About The Toasty Smore: The Toasty Smore is a family-owned and operated cottage food business. Our gourmet marshmallows are handcrafted in a home kitchen, not inspected by the Department of State Health Services or a local health department. However, we are fully accredited food handlers, as required under the Health and Safety Code. These items were prepared using equipment that also processes tree nuts, eggs, and gluten. If you have specific concerns, please contact us.

Why You’ll Love Them:

  • Versatile Delights: Perfect for hot chocolate, s'mores, and a variety of desserts.

  • Artisanal Quality: Each marshmallow is handmade with premium ingredients, including beef gelatin.

  • Customizable: Choose from a wide range of unique and delicious flavors.

Order Now: Bring home the delightful taste of handcrafted gourmet marshmallows in your favorite flavors. Order now and experience the artisanal quality of The Toasty Smore!

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Customer Reviews

Based on 42 reviews
83%
(35)
12%
(5)
5%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
100.0
100.0
V
Vickie

Absolutely delicious! Arrived quickly and super well packed to stay fresh! Shop was so lovely and accommodating for my family’s allergies. I highly recommend this shop!

K
Kelci

This was the first time I had gourmet marshmallows and they were really good! They are quite sweet so I cut them up into small pieces to eat a little bit at a time. But they also last a long time.

D
Delanie

Super yummy! For sure ordering again :)

k
kandieks

Fast shipping and great product!

l
lawrence

Amazing product. Quality tastes great the variety was spectacular. Super accommodating and quick response from the shop literally you'd want from your Etsy shop.

123

You may also like

Recently viewed

Customer Reviews

Based on 42 reviews
83%
(35)
12%
(5)
5%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
100.0
100.0
V
Vickie

Absolutely delicious! Arrived quickly and super well packed to stay fresh! Shop was so lovely and accommodating for my family’s allergies. I highly recommend this shop!

K
Kelci

This was the first time I had gourmet marshmallows and they were really good! They are quite sweet so I cut them up into small pieces to eat a little bit at a time. But they also last a long time.

D
Delanie

Super yummy! For sure ordering again :)

k
kandieks

Fast shipping and great product!

l
lawrence

Amazing product. Quality tastes great the variety was spectacular. Super accommodating and quick response from the shop literally you'd want from your Etsy shop.

123